Category: AllFuckedUp

Risk Mitigation: Test More Random for Shell Ejection

cli Leave a comment

This is the follow-up article about lens #16, the lens of risk mitigation from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell. If you buy books through the links in this article I will get a small commission for that.

I will play with the random factor for shell ejection, they currently look a bit like a waterfall as I only have random for the vertical component of the ejection force. So I tried to add as well random for the horizontal force. I will have to do this comparison for all my weapons that I want to use in the game.

For me, B looks a bit more vivid and a bit more out of control, actually exactly what I want to achieve. Anyway, I made a tweet but this time no feedback. I guess it doesn’t make a big difference. I go with a tiny bit more random and that’s it, looks more vivid.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

Risk Mitigation: Test Bigger Muzzles

cli Leave a comment

This is the follow-up article about lens #16, the lens of risk mitigation from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell. If you buy books through the links in this article I will get a small commission for that.

I will try different sizes of muzzles and add a bit more random to it to see if that could make a difference. As well as experiment with different sizes for every gun. As well add some random to make it more vivid.

For fast prototyping, I need a simple way to switch between the weapons. There are a couple of ways. I can make a pickup command and exchange the gun with the previous gun and just put all guns in a row. Or add them programmatically and make a switch weapon button for this test.

I made a four-panel gif image with https://www.kapwing.com labeled with A: Constant muzzle with a flashlight, B: Random muzzle with a flashlight, C: Constant muzzle no light, and D: Random muzzle no light.

And made a tweet to get some feedback which is the best variant.

I also asked friends and family members. The outcome is that a bit more of the votes like B the best as it looks more vivid. The second large group preferred A because the muzzle leaks through the floor if I use a random muzzle size, which is simple to fix. Many said a tiny less random would be beneficial. There was one vote for C as the gradient muzzle would not fit the art style.

Furthermore, that way I could engage many more people on my tweet, much more than I expected.

So thanks a lot for helping me out to find the best muzzle style which is important for my game as it lives from the weapon, shell ejection, recoil, and muzzle. I will have at least 3 different sizes of muzzles, one for nine-millimeter weapons I have, one for the soldier rifles like M1 or M4, and one for the bigger guns. I will probably have to fine-tune this further.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

Lens #16: The Lens of Risk Mitigation

cli Leave a comment

The lens #16, the lens of risk mitigation from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell. If you buy books through the links int this article I will get a small commission for that.

First of all, this lens is about figuring out the worst-case scenarios, what could go wrong, or what could hold my game back from being great. This is to stop thinking positively about my game. Tim Ferriss also has this in his book The 4 Hour Workweek, to overcome the fear he suggest to write down the biggest nightmare you can imagine could happen if you, for example, quit your job and start an own business and from there mitigate those risks and find solutions. And it is also about testing your ideas with prototypes. There are similarities in these books. One is game design the other is about automating your company. About 80:20. Fascinating.

  • What could keep this game from being great?
  • How can I stop that from happening?

My levels might be boring to play. So I started a series of mini levels. My first mini levels are all about the double-barrel shotgun. I keep them minimalistic to test if the levels are fun or boring to play. they are super minimalistic and super quickly done. Perfect for prototyping. It’s already clear that this might be fun, as I can motivate people for speed runs. It’s fun because you can pick up the gun and ammo and while you jump up to the platform with enemies your gun is ready and loaded. This leads to a possible smooth speedrun through a level.

I don’t have enough surprises and interactive things. One of the problems is you can leave a room without killing anything in it. Not sure if I want that. To hinder that I could have doors that open after I killed all enemies. But is this fun? I will quickly implement a “reached goal system” to find out if this is the right way. The goal system can be triggered by enemies linked to it or a simple switch. The goal system simply opens the door to the next level.

The graphical appearance is probably my main problem. I will experiment with different styles of simple blocks. And make the battle engaging the player with massive effects. Keep an eye on small details like papers that whirl up in the air will you pass. Make the ejected shells more vivid by adding a bit more random.

So there are a couple of things I would like to test:

The levels have to be addictive and be playable in many different ways. This is not just the look but also the feel of it. The player needs a reward for every accomplished goal.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

M163 Vulcan from Sketch to Model

cli Leave a comment

I modeled my M163 Vulcan tank with blender 3D for my game. The plan is that a soldier can control that tank alone, which of curse in reality it needs more people at least a gunner and a driver. And because one soldier can control this tank the player can take out that soldier and take over the tank. The next step is to bring the tank into my game and do some shooting prototyping to see if it looks cool. The real old M163 Vulcan does eject the shells visibly which fits in my concept so well.

Lens #15: The Lens of the Eight Filters

cli 2 Comments

for the feedback.The lens #15, the lens of the eight filters from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell. If you buy this book through this link I will get a small commission for that.

This lens is one of those which I have to evolve as not everything is already here to answer the questions. Some of them I can answer right now, others I can not yet and I have to do this later in the process. This is one thing I learned about these filters, they can not just be applied in a specific order, this is more an iterative process and I have to apply certain filters over and over again. I don’t know yet how I will do that. Probably I have to write follow-up articles for this.

My design has to pass eight filters

  • Does the game feel right?
  • Will the target audience like this game enough?
  • Is this a well-designed game?
  • Is this game novel enough?
  • Will this game sell?
  • Is it technically possible to build this game?
  • Does this game meet our social and community goals?
  • Doe the playtesters enjoy this game enough?

I did a lot of testing to get it fluid enough and test all the functionality and I didn’t get bored to play it through. Just jumping, shooting around is satisfying and fun to do.

I think I missed to write a game for a specific demographic audience, I didn’t think of that, but I still can change or figure out what this target audience could be. Is it more for retro gamers? It is a single-player game so far, that might limit the audience. At the game show, the previous prototype was played more by young people the age between 12 – 16 years old. But the violent content could make this a problem. I might have to make dying less bloody. Even though I do just eject red cubes it does look like the soldier exploded into meat chunks. But as it is not too violent it might be playable from the age of 14. The cuteness factor I plan to build in should also make this game playable for girls not only boys.

I need to think about make co-op an option in this game so that you can play it with a friend. But that would be challenging on many levels and I don’t have any idea how to balance the levels for co-op mode. It might even be much more challenging to play it in coop mode, as bullets are lethal for everybody.

Throughout the process, the game starts to be well designed and I have a very good understanding of where I want to go and how it has to look. I like the ideas of bosses that catapult me to the next room or level or world (see Lens #13).

I think the weapons I use for this shoot’em’up platform game is novel, most often you just have a gun and can shoot endless, no need to pick up ammo for that, no reloading, and often fantasy weapons. My weapons mimic real weapons and the shell ejection is different from weapon to weapon. And you have to pick up ammo as this is a limited resource. So I think this is kind of novel.

If this game will sell I don’t know. It is my first game I will sell at all. So I kinda can not answer this question properly or I don’t know how to figure out if it will sell or not.

It is technically possible to build this game. All the main features are already there including saving the game state, die and get reborn at the last entry point with a properly reset player state, and as well AI-driven entities. I don’t see hurdles on a technical level.

There is currently no community and I have to think about this aspect as well. I don’t know yet how to do that, but it needs probably a forum where the community can exchange ideas and expectations with me but as well with each other.

And last but not least the most important questions, do playtesters enjoy the game enough. I’m currently working hard on playable very rough levels without any eye candies as I want to do this later. I need to find playtesters that would like to just play the test levels through. I will write an article to organize that. And prepare a checklist for the feedback as well.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

Enter Game, Switch Level, and Die

cli Leave a comment

To make my first couple of testable levels, I need a clear understanding of how to preserve the game state and how to reset the level when I die and also how many times I wanna die and where I will get reborn, and how I get reborn.

Soft Requirements

So I made a simple list of some soft requirements.

  • Making dying a painless thing
  • Getting reborn at a save spot to be able to try again
  • Seeing the relicts of past battles I fought
  • Picking up the game after a day without losing anything

Hard Requirements

The soft requirements lead to a set of hard requirements. The hard requirements are easier to make happen in code than a fluffy set of soft requirements.

Connect the Rooms
The rooms exit and entrance are connected that way I know where I have to place the player after he left the room through a certain door or exit.

Player Enters a New Game
If I start a new game I need a default entrance point for the player and this is only for the very first room anyway.

  • Drop the player at the rooms default location
  • Load the room in its initial state

Player Switch the Room
In case I die I wanna back the inial state of my ammo and weaponry to have a fair chance to be able to clear this room.

  • Store the state of the current room
  • Remove the current room
  • Keep all collected and not used up ammo and weapons
  • Load the room you switch either the saved or the initial one
  • Drop the player at the connected entrance of the new room
  • Store ammo and weapon state at this point

Player Dies
I must get back the state I had when I entered the room to be able to clear this room else I might run out of ammo over time and the chance to make it through that room goes to zero.

  • Drop the player on his last entrance
  • Remove all items the player collected in the current room
  • Load either the saved room or the initial room
  • Load ammo and weapon state

Player Dies in Not Finished Room
I have one special case, if I enter a new room collect ammo and weapons, go back to old rooms and use up all ammo in those old cleared rooms, I have no chance to make it through the new not yet cleared room. So I need the following rule.

  • If you die in a not yet cleared room reset that room to initial state

First Footage

A short footage about switching levels with the rules from above. Enjoy.

There is still some problems with falling stuff if I left a level. This falling stuff will stop falling if I leave the level and continue falling if I reenter the level.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

Lens #14: The Lens of the Problem Statement

cli Leave a comment

The lens #14, the lens of the problem statement from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell.

Design is about solving problems, but if you don’t know what problem you solve then it is pretty hard to design something, it’s like designing in a vacuum. This lens can be applied over and over again. Game development is based on iterations. I will just evolve this article over time.

The better the problem statement the better the solution for it. So what are the questions I have to answer

  • What problem do I really want to solve?
  • Did I make assumptions about these games that have nothing to do with its true purpose?
  • Is a game really the best solution?
  • How do I know if the problem is solved.

What problem do I really want to solve? How can I make an enjoyable gun game using minimalistic graphics?

Did I make assumptions about this game that has nothing to do with its true purpose? The assumption I made is it has to be a platform game as I initially wanted to explore this genre from a programming point of view. But it has nothing to do with its true purpose, I guess I could make even a full 3D game. But this is kind of a limitation I have as a one-person studio, I simply need a very simple way to do that game as I have to fill it with game content. So better it is a packed small platformer than an almost empty 3D game.

Is a game really the best solution? This is entirely about a video game. I think the question should be more is a platform game really the best solution? I just use a platform game as it is the cheapest way to make a game as a single person studio. But I want to focus on the action part and use the platform environment as battlefields and story elements.

How do I know if the problem is solved I think I only will know that by playtesting. I have to focus on playtesting very very soon with playable levels and evaluate the feedback.

I get a small commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only have books in this section which I bought myself and which I love. No bullshit.

Lens #13: The Lens of Infinite Inspiration

cli Leave a comment

The lens #13, the lense of infinite inspiration from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell.

The core of this lens is to look everywhere else than to other games.

  • What experience in my life would I like to share with others?
  • In what small way can I capture the essence of that experience and put it into the game?

I will make a collection of thoughts and in the end, I will apply lens #2

Here some inspirations

  • A smooth skateboard run in a bowl
  • Martial Art
  • Hellboy comics

Smooth Skateboard run in a Bowl

I love to watch skateboard clips, especially smooth bowl runs. With this slight scratch sound when the rider corrects his board with all four wheels on the ground. My aim here will be to make moving the character smooth, precise, and nice. The player should be able to move through a world smoothly and fluidly. This will include a lot of testing and adjusting. The problem I face here is that adjusting the player control will affect the existing levels. A slight change in the jump height, speed, or friction can have a great impact on the levels.

Applying lens #2 leads to the following 3 questions

  • What experience do I want the player to have?
  • What is essential to that experience?
  • How can I capture this essence in our game?

The player should get a feeling of great control over the character. The walkthrough must be fluid and to the point.

Like the smooth and almost effortless-looking run of a skateboarder in a bowl or skatepark, the player should be able to smoothly navigate through the levels. It should always give the player a very good control over the character.

To navigate through the levels smoothly the levels should be crafted in a way that the player doesn’t pump his head, the platforms are reachable without being pixel exact, as well you always see where you go, there is no blind rattlesnake hole. Whenever you have to jump blind, make sure it is always a safe jump without surprises on the landing spot, this could be a storytelling element.

Martial Art

Martial art is my choice of sport. It trains your brain, your body, and your balance. To watch skilled martial artist is a joy, the moves are seamless, almost effortless, the weapons are super precise. I love choreographed fight scene, compared to a real fight, that looks just beautiful, almost like a dance.

Let’s apply lens #2 here as well and answer the three questions.

  • What experience do I want the player to have?
  • What is essential to that experience?
  • How can I capture this essence in our game?

It’s important that the player feels always capable throughout the gameplay without feeling bored or overpowered. The control over the weapons and aiming while walking and shooting should be smooth and precise. Even if the controller isn’t that precise the game has to be, that should be an experience I want the player has.

Martial art is about a combination of attack and defense patterns nicely rowed up to defeat the opponent. The martial artist has great control over his weapons, everything is smooth, fast, and precise. There is no hesitation, no struggle, no fuss. Even modern action movies are filled with martial art and that makes them so enjoyable to watch. It’s not just the explosions and the fx, but as well the moves, attack, and defense during a gunfight.

The aiming of the guns should not be fully automated, but if you start shooting at an enemy it should keep track to a certain degree. The player has to point roughly in the direction of the enemies and the auto-aiming should then take part. I’m thinking of having an automated switch weapon, whenever you are too close to enemies, nevertheless the player should be able to oversteer the choice of the weapons. Maybe I can make this configurable.

Hellboy Comic

I admire the Hellboy comic style from Mike Mignola, it’s dark, simple in a way and hence full of little details. I like the sceneries he set’s up in those comics. One of the stories starts at a door and as soon hellboy opens it hell breaks loose. The battles are often short but intense. And it’s always a boss fight for hellboy.

Let’s tackle lens #2

  • What experience do I want the player to have?
  • What is essential to that experience?
  • How can I capture this essence in our game?

One of the things I like from Hellboy is the silent moment and the intense but short fights. Sometimes he gets catapulted to the next level of the story. I’m thinking of having some silent moments to tell a story in this game. But fights should be always intense, no matter if it is a boss fight or not. I’m not yet sure if it will work.

Essential to this experience is, that there is not continues battles going on like in a shmup but as well some story elements, like silent moments or falling down a hole and find your self in a new room, after battling a boss (which might have survived so he can show up later again).

I think by adding a transition from one battle to another and after boss fighting getting catapulted to another world even. Like in hellboy where he went to hell after the witch grabbed his heart. So actually hellboy looses but this doesn’t mean to be the end of the game. I like that very much and gives this dying a new perspective. I kinda have an idea, but not written in stone. I have to try this experience and see if that could work.

I like this idea and I accidentally stumbled over it in analyzing what exactly I like from this comic, what underlying mechanics which drives the story to the weirdest places on earth and the underworld.

I get commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only put stuff in this section I also would buy or I already bought

Lens #12: The Lens of Resonance

cli 1 Comment

I’m now at lens #12, the lense of resonance from The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses written by Jesse Schell. It is about to elevate the game from craft to art. A quite an ambitious lens. Not sure if All Fucked Up has this resonance. I wanted it to be cute and simple and, well, doable. A resonating theme, but simple.

Let’s reach for the stars and tackle the four questions from the book.

  • What is it about my game that feels powerful and special?
  • When I describe my game to people, what ideas get them excited?
  • If I had no constraints of any kind, what would this game be like?
  • I have certain instincts about how this game should be. What is driving those instincts?

Firing weapons is one of the most powerful things in this game. It looks good, it feels good, it sounds good. I love the fact that I do not visualize the guns by applying it to the character but with how the shells get ejected. The shotgun makes a soft sound while ejecting the two shells after firing. Also, the sound when the shells fall on the ground gives a little extra. I watched quite some gun training videos on youtube and besides fast reload there is also gun switch from handgun to rifle and back. I was thinking of that and will make this part of the game that you can switch between a primary weapon (rifle) and a secondary weapon (handgun). Rifles are more precise on targets farther away than handguns. Handguns are better for close-range battles than rifles. But also if you run out of ammo a gun switch can save your ass.


M4 with a high fire rate, 30 rounds mags, fast reload

The very few feedback I got so far was mainly that firing the weapon looks good and to the point. My children and my girlfriend like the cuteness of the characters. The hero has a funny side which makes it fun to play but also to watch. Whenever we talk about that they have a bunch of ideas to make it more fun.


M249 with a fast fire rate, 100 rounds mags, slow reload

The imagination to be in a badass movie with the fun moments and cool quotes are something I want to craft. The gameplay has to be smooth and precise and the badass quotes to the point at the right time. The action should be loud and intense. But as well some silent and beautiful moments to add a strong contrast. Even with no constraints, I would like to have the levels simple with a focus on the cute characters. I would like to have a proper walk animation. Slapstick reactions like screaming, laughing, cursing, exciting, and more. But as well more details like falling leaves or flying paper when we rush through an office, grass which reacts, or fireflies.


M1 semi automatic, 8 rounds mags, slow reload

My instincts tell me that I’m on the right way I intensive the gun mechanics and the funny side of the hero. I simplified the tileset as I would like to add details differently and subtly. So my focus is entirely on

  1. Making the guns feel good, look good, sound good, and super precise
  2. Focus on cute animations, reactions, and design
  3. Add subtle small reacting things to add more love to the game

It is amazing how these lenses helped me to improve the game. I have a much better understanding now on how this game has to look and feel. It helps me to drop the things which do not help the game. The focus is so much sharper now than at the beginning of this experiment. I’m curious where I end up when I’m finished with this book.

I get commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only put stuff in this section I also would buy or I already bought

Shoot in All Directions

cli Leave a comment

I can now shoot in all directions with my little cute hero. And you can see he enjoys it a lot! My game goes now the action game path with a very simple level design. The idea is to improve the visuals with small little details. The ejected shells are one sample, the hearth if he collects new ammo, and the funny lauthter if he shoots like crazy. I plan to add more things which interacts with the hero or any NPC, like crickets which fly aroung and get disturbed in the the bullet hell.

I think it’s now quite hard to aim on something and as ammo is a limited resource I probably need kind of an automatic aim. The idea is that if there is something to shoot and I aim in a directions the automatic aim to the next shootable thing in that direction if it is in range. But I need to do first game testing. This is actually the next step any way to have a set of simple levels and let people play them so I can collect feedback. In the past I did that with steam, I probably also will look into itch.io as well.

I get commissions for purchases made through the following links, I only put stuff in this section I also would buy or I already bought